Money for Nothing

 It is difficult to avoid all the hype about crypto-currencies these days, even here in backwaters of the world like Northern Ireland.  My cynical nature means that I am never really likely to be a fan of these, but I'm not particularly knowledgeable about them, and a recent TV program both astounded me and piqued my interest into finding out just how flimsy their value really is.  So here's the disclaimer; this is all my opinion.  Feel free to have your own, and better yet if you disagree,  reply to this piece and show me where I am wrong.  I am not particularly against the companies mentioned here; I personally just choose to avoid them like the plague.

The best known crypto is obviously Bitcoin, so I have restricted my scant research to it.  Life is too short to start trying to find differences between them.

We all know how the real world economy works.  People make things, grow crops, write music or books, make movies, mine commodities like copper from the ground, or any one of thousands of things that people will pay for.  In the good old days governments kept an eye on the amount of economic activity in their territories and regulated the amount of money circulating there to keep things like inflation in check.  Of course over the last number of years that strange idea called quantitative easing means that most governments just printed (a metaphorical term, since much of it was just increases in available credit) more and more, and more, and more of the stuff, but at least this will have to be paid back sometime.  The only bad point about the pay back is that the money went to the richest in society, but the payback will come from taxes, and of course the rich are very good at avoiding these.

Now to Bitcoin.  Firstly the one similarity that I can see.  It can be used to pay for goods and services, and apparently some people do to a very limited degree. Now the differences.

1)  Currencies like UK Pounds, Euros, Dollars and all the rest have the official back up and support of their country.  If you have a few Dollars in your pocket, you have in essence the full 52 states behind you along with a central bank and a full legal apparatus.  A dollar may be just a piece of paper, but unless the entire USA suddenly disappears off the face of the globe, you have something that is almost physical.  Bitcoin by contrast has, so far as I can see, no backup whatsoever.  The Wikipedia entry on it states that no one even knows who set it up!  If you want to cash your Bitcoins in in a crisis, then where do you go, or will it all just melt into the ether that it originally came from?

2)  A UK pound has a reasonably set value.  I know that if I go to the shops today, I will have to hand over 1.3 of them to get a 2 litre carton of milk.  OK, inflation will gradually erode this over time, but even if you could hand over a Bitcoin in a shop to buy milk, how many of them would need?  The value of bitcoin is hugely volatile so although I largely know where I stand by holding Pounds, I may be poor or rich with Bitcoin, but predicting this from one day to the next is always going to be difficult.  This is because the Bitcoin value is not set against its buying power, but almost exclusively against the speculation of supply and demand in it.  Ok there are currency speculators on ordinary currencies, but this is based on very small changes relative to one another which are largely regulated by the economic performance of the countries.  And, when one trader wins in this process, another loses.  This is simple double entry accounting.  What is the value of Bitcoin based on, other than one person wanting to buy into it  a little more than another person?  Apparently Thailand is currently the world centre of Bitcoin trading by the way.

3)   I have already mentioned that Bitcoin's origins are something of a mystery, but there are more and more of them in existence every day.  This seems ridiculous for something that is by and large only a medium for speculation.  The law of supply and demand states that with more and more of them in existence, their value should drop unless the level of speculation in them is increasing at a faster rate.  So more and more people must be getting involved to keep this thing going.  If you have ever heard of the name Charles Ponzi, and the supposed money making scheme that he gave his name to, you might well see some similarities with Bitcoin.  It seems to me that any profits being made from Bitcoin are solely funded by the investments of others.  That is dangerous in the extreme, especially given the extent that this thing has been allowed to grow. With increasing numbers of Bitcoin in the market every day, and a relatively fixed number of investors, a time must come when the market is satiated, and then Bitcoin's price will collapse.

4)  Where do Bitcoins come from? It seems that Bitcoins can be created by a process called 'mining'.  There is even a company called Argo Blockchain listed on the London Stock Exchange which exists solely to mine Bitcoin.  I had a look at its web site to see if there was an explanation of exactly how this is done, but although the site has a page titled 'What we Do', it simply lists the company's data centres and its environmental policy.  What they do remains vague.  PayPal sends me a message about Bitcoin once a week or so because apparently you can now trade Bitcoin on that platform.  Below, from one of these are what PayPal say are 'some of their 'most popular questions answered'.  People can dig deeper, but the ones presented are so shallow, I would hate to think that anyone buys into Bitcoin on the basis of information like this.


So, 'mining' means that simply by running an algorithm on a computer you can create wealth out of nothing?  You still consume the earth's precious resources like electricity, but all that happens is the number on a spreadsheet gets bigger.  Nothing of any use is created, no one gets fed or housed or any of the other physical things that are actually important in life and society.  If this does not prove to be an even worse scam than those sub prime mortgages that incinerated the worlds banking system back in 2007, I will be hugely surprised.  The emperor has new clothes, and they are made of Bitcoins.


See this BBC article to see just how quickly the values of Crypto can change!  Cryptocrash: ‘I was arrested for knocking on Luna boss's door' - BBC News



Comments

  1. Geoff James21 May 2022 at 23:34

    Completely agree with you Ian. Bitcoin reeks of snake oil and as always, people are sucked in with the promise of easy returns then complain when it turns to custard. With the current state of the world, our investments have taken a hit but at least they're based on tangible assets and are unlikely to vanish in a puff of smoke. I'd have thought that in the current economic climate, Bitcoin holdings and the like will be the first casualties in any crash.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Feel free to leave a comment: I don't use or sell your data, and you will not receive any spam mail as a result.

Popular posts from this blog

Local History of the worst possible kind! The story of Carnage Hill.

This post was shamelessly copied from a local history book, now out of print, that used to be available in pdf format on line.     It is only one section of a much larger and more broadly based book.  All credit is then due to the book's author, and to the team who originally published it.  Trinity College, Dublin have now scanned an published a host of records from the 1641 rebellion.  More details relating to the numerous massacres and other events from the this rebellion can be seen here: https://1641.tcd.ie/ Those who have travelled the main road between Bangor and Belfast will know the corner known as ‘the Devil’s Elbow’, which is located just before the junction leading to Seahill/ Rockport.   On the left side of the road when travelling from Bangor there is a small road leading up into the Holywood hills.   It is now called Carney Hill, but according to this article that name derives from Carnage Hill.   To see where it got this name read on.   Many thanks are due t
Read more

Welcome

Image
Welcome to Old Ireland.   My initial idea for this site was to cover only classic vehicles, but since classicireland.ie was already taken and the best alternative I could find was this one, my thoughts for the site began to broaden.   A lot of the inspiration for this comes from the few magazines for which I have written articles.   Let’s get these mentioned early, because you should not be surprised to see a little of their influence here.   Real Classic is subscription only in print, but also has an excellent site at https://www.real-classic.co.uk/ , where Frank, Rowena and a host of writers entertain and inspire.   Then there is Minnesota Motorcycle Monthly, formerly in print monthly, but now only on line at http://mnmotorcycle.com / (unfortunately now obsolete.  You will need to use the Wayback machine to find it).   MMM’s archives could keep you reading happily for months, and the like it or not truths told by Thomas Day (Geezer with a grudge: see his own site at http://geez
Read more

And then what?

 If you have been reading these ramblings for a while, you may have read here:  The Burning Question of Our Times. (oldandireland.blogspot.com , that my conscience is giving me grief for my many years of burning petrol for fun.  You may even have seen this, posted way back in September 2019:  Old Ireland, new technology. The search for reliable solar water heating. (oldandireland.blogspot.com) , where I was looking for a good alternative for a solar thermal system that we had fitted on our roof. The tubes for it were made by a local company called Thermomax, and supposedly had a twenty year guarantee when we bought them.  They broke repeatedly and eventually catastrophically which meant that they were never likely to pay for themselves, and the guarantee turned out to be worth nothing because Thermomax went bankrupt.  Great. Because of my experience with those thermal tubes, there was no way that I was going to fit anything similar any time soon.  Still, I needed something to assuage t
Read more

Two Wrongs…….

 This has been bugging me ever since Hamas were stupid/ callous enough to raid Israel on the 7 th October. What did they expect would happen with the current right-wing government that is in power in Israel?  There is a lot of truth in what Israel are saying about Hamas using their own peoples lives for propaganda. However, and this is a very big however, there is, or at least there should be, a huge difference between the terrorist organisation Hamas and a legitimate state like Israel.   I’ll give you a couple of rough, home grown definitions that might hopefully illustrate the point.   We have a lot of experience in dealing with terrorists here in Northern Ireland.   What Israel is doing categorically will not work.   They will not get rid of Hamas, in fact heavy handed tactics like they are applying will only drive more volunteers into the ranks of Hamas. 1)       A terrorist organisation does not follow the rule of law, that's why they are an illegal organisation.   Th
Read more

Tilly.

Image
  In January 2010 I was idly browsing through the ads for pet dogs on Gumtree when I spotted a very poor quality picture of a mainly white dog with some black markings.   The dog was sitting looking up at someone just out of shot, as if obedient to them, (Knowing Tilly now, I suspect treats may have been involved).   The description in the ad was somewhat less than detailed.   She was described as being a mix between a Bearded Collie and an Irish Wolf Hound, and the people that had her, wanted rid of her for free.   That, and a contact number was about it.   Even in the blurry shot on the ad she looked like a beautiful dog, and I was intrigued.   It had been around ten years since our last dog had died (aged 17), but at the time, my wife was nursing her elderly mother, and with a Wolf Hound in the mix I presumed that this would be a very large dog, so I didn’t mention it, thinking that someone would soon take on a dog like that.   Shortly after, the ad disappeared, so I thought tha
Read more

Information overload.

Image
  HED Map Viewer 2024 (arcgis.com) The map showing archaeological sites here in Northern Ireland that I used in my last piece is well worth a mention in its own right (see the link at the top of this page).  It is a government site, but is open to the public, so there are no issues in using it.  There are many layers, from ones showing shipwrecks and aircraft crashes, to historic maps, battle sites, and even lidar surveys in some areas.   Pick on  a link that interests you, and click in.  There are often further links to other sites and even back to the original archaeological reports on many of them.  To those who don't live in Northern Ireland, sorry, you will have to find something similar for your own locality.  But here, there is a real warren of interesting information and links that will keep anyone with an interest occupied for hours. Many of the sites local to me I knew about, but there are a few that are new to me, including an intriguing liner stone feature that is under
Read more

On eating out.

  I’ve mentioned before that we were building an extension.   Because of it we lost our kitchen for a few months and were living on what we could either microwave or air fry in the house.   That is a pretty boring diet, so we also had more carry outs than we have had in years and have been doing the rounds of local pub grub establishments and restaurants. I have to say that for a town the size of Bangor, the restaurants despite not being cheap to dine in are almost universally pretty poor.   Buying wine in a restaurant costs a lot, but what you get in return for your hard earned cash has frequently been not much more than vinegar.   Why is it that £6 to £7 quid can get you a pretty decent wine in a supermarket, yet three or four times that amount in a restaurant buys something only fit to put on chips? Restaurants here have been complaining for years about people not eating out as much as they used to yet provide a not very enjoyable eating experience when you do go out with medioc
Read more

Island life.

Image
OK, Islay has nothing to do with Ireland, but it is only twenty five miles off our coast, and the scenery and culture would be familiar to anyone who lives here in Ireland.  This story was originally published way back in 2008 in Minnesota Motorcycle Monthly, a great magazine in its time.  I thought this was sufficiently far removed from the current Covid crisis to give us all a small reminder of better times. Enjoy. __________ My home in Northern Ireland provides scope for many good scenic runs on a bike.  One familiar and rightly popular local run follows the coast north through County Antrim from the narrow confines of the Irish Sea to the open Atlantic.  The two waters meet off Ballycastle, a harbour sheltered by the rugged cliffs of Rathlin Island 3 miles offshore.  Look west from here on a good day, and the coast winds off toward Donegal and the open ocean, look north and off Scotland’s coast, the horizon is broken by Islay, the first of the Hebrides islands, and by the hi
Read more

MOT prep for modern cars.

Image
  My wife's car (MX5) was up for MOT  recently so, well  in advance,  I checked it over.  The only usual wear and tear mechanical items that needed replaced were the rear brake pads.  There is nothing unusual in this, and it is an easy job but from previous experience it tends to have side effects in these cars (see later).  At the front there was a problem that I was not expecting. These cars come with Bilstein suspension as standard.  The rubber boots on the front ones had broken up, exposing the damper shafts to all the vile salt and corrosion that our winter roads provide.  In my humble opinion this should not happen on a ten year old car.  For example, the boots protecting the front suspension on my 47 year old BMW bike are still the original parts, and are still fine.  It is all down to the specification of the rubber in these parts as set by the factory.  But the boots had to be changed, especially given the price of replacement Bilstein suspension! This is not a particularl
Read more